Sweet Potato Casserole – A Thanksgiving Tradition

Hard to believe that Thanksgiving is this Thursday.  I’m very lucky that my sister-in-law has volunteered to handle the dinner for many years now with contributions from the hungry moochers.  She handles the turkey with many side dishes, another sister-in-law is the pie maker extraordinaire, and I bring the sweet potato casserole which must go over well since I’ve been asked to repeat this one for years now.  I think the reason is that we can call it a vegetable and put it on the table with the main course but with the brown sugar topping, it gives us a chance to start on dessert early.  This can be made up a day ahead of time & just reheated with the turkey and it serves plenty of hungry people.

3        Cups mashed sweet potatoes (4-5 med)
½       Cup milk
¾      Cup granulated sugar
½       Stick melted butter
2        Eggs
½       teas salt
1        TBL vanilla extract

Boil sweet potatoes until tender.  Quantity is hard to tell with sweet potatoes since they can vary so much in size.  Don’t worry if you have too many because you can always add a little extra milk if it seems too dry.  Use a mixer to beat the sweet potatoes smooth.  This calls for a 1/2 cup of milk but add it slowly so you can strive for a smooth texture similar to mashed potatoes, definitely not runny.  Ease up on the milk or if you over-do that, just put 1 egg in rather than 2.

Combine the rest of the ingredient with mixer until smooth.  Remove any obvious strings (usually stuck to beaters) & hard lumps.   Pour into 13×9” (approx) glass oven proof dish.

1        Cup light brown sugar                ½       Cup flour
½       Stick softened butter                  1        Cup chopped pecans

Mix by hand or w/pastry blender.  Sprinkle over potato mixture.  Bake at 350F approximately 30 minutes.  Serves 10.  Can be prepared the night before and reheated, covered for about 30-45 minutes.

5 thoughts on “Sweet Potato Casserole – A Thanksgiving Tradition

  1. I found your recipe! I might make this for December 12th – when my boys and their families – and my twin brother and his family – all get together. I know this will be a BIG hit. (I didn’t see a ‘pin it’ button… so I’m pinning it the old fashioned way!


      • Sorry about no photo…like a fool, I deleted a bunch of photos not thinking and they no longer show up. Just an update on this one, the past few times I’ve made it I have skipped the milk because it should have the consistency of mashed potatoes. If you boil the sweet potato until soft, it doesn’t need the extra moisture.

        Also a friend made it and she thought it was too much butter – so that’s a matter of preference. I tend to use a lot. It’s the brown sugar topping that everyone seems to go crazy over.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s